What If there was a multiverse where Glinda's meltdown lead her to sing "Someone Gets Hurt" from Mean Girls? Or if Collins from Rent sang a Whitney Houston power ballad to his dying liver?? Audiences joined us for an SEVEN exciting evenings of What Ifs, as their favorite characters sang songs that they've never sung before, all while interacting with characters from other shows. Creator and music director Jorden Amir had both familiar and new faces from Broadway and beyond, sing unexpected combinations of the most beloved musicals. Audiences were shocked in all seven parts of this series, as they pondered the question, What If?...
_edited.png)
July 27th, 2026
Cast: Bella Aboulhosn, Miki Abraham, Faith Alhadeff, Angelina Amato, Bryson Battle, Savannah Lee Birdsong, Connor DeRoche, Carissa Gaughran, Callie Henrysen, Sarah Isola, Jules Kessler, Cooper LaMontagne, Weston Chandler Long, Jonathan Masse, Michael Moretti, Ava Newman, Mason Olshavsky, Samia Posadas, Skyler Reed Lipkind, Cole Thompson, Zalah Vallien
–––––
Music Director: Jorden Amir
Key 2: Jayla McLennan
Guitar: Peter Douskalis
Bass: Lindsay Rosenberg
Drums: Ethan Gueldenzopf
_edited.png)
June 1st, 2025
Cast: Faith Alhadeff, Angelina Amato, Jorden Barrow, Bryson Battle, Kaileigh Fiorillo, Ellie Fishman, Isabela Garcia, Catie Gorton, Callie Henrysen, Grace Hodgett-Young, Cooper LaMontagne, Lizzy Legregin, Isabel Leoni, Abby McDonough, Juliette Ojeda, Mikayla Renfrow, Nadia Jewel Vito, Ayden Weinstein, Alyssa Wray, Maeve Zamuner
–––––
Music Director: Jorden Amir
Key 2: Jayla McLennan
Guitar: Peter Douskalis
Bass: Lindsay Rosenberg
Drums: Ethan Gueldenzopf
August 11th, 2024
Cast: Angelina Amato, Brayden Bambino, Natalie Kaye Clater, Helora Danna, Brielle Diaz Withers, Kaileigh Fiorillo, Isabela Garcia, Sarah Isola, Halle Just, Mikey Mousaw, Katie Nieto, Molly Jobe, Juliette Ojeda, Moana Poyer, Chloe Pugh, Allie Trimm, Ayden Weinstein, David Wright
–––––
Music Director: Jorden Amir
Guitar: Kenji Golden
Bass: Lindsay Rosenberg
Drums: Ethan Gueldenzopf
March 17th, 2024
Cast: Catalina Almeida, Angelina Amato, Zack Bliss, Erin Rose Doyle, Gabe Escobar, Isabela Garcia, Haley Herman, Amelie Jacobs, Frankie Leoni, Rocco Leoni, Jake Levy, Nathalia Mendoza, Mason Olshavsky, Elizabeth Ritacco, Carrie St. Louis, Noah Sucato, Ayden Weinstein, Brielle Diaz Withers
–––––
Music Director: Jorden Amir
Bass: Rocco Leoni
Drums: Ethan Gueldenzopf
Cast: Catalina Almeida, Jack Austin, Noah Andrew Chartrand, Helora Danna, Matthew Fecko, Sarah Isola, Amelie Jacobs, Gryphyn Karimloo, Cameron Park-Miller, Giulia Nicole, Moana Poyer, Lilliannie Arie Urgent, Brielle Diaz Withers
–––––
Music Director Jorden Amir
Guitar: Tyler Doucette
Bass: Tony Gnerre
Drums: Ethan Gueldenzopf
July 9th, 2023
Cast: Joe Bliss, Helora Danna, Katy Geraghty, Mia Cherise Hall, Callie Henrysen, Gryphyn Karimloo, Abi Monterey, Carolina Rial, Jonalyn Saxer, David Wright
Music Director: Jorden Amir
Guitar: Tony Gnerre
Bass: Lindsay Rosenberg
Drums: Justin Huang
December 5th, 2022
Cast: Martha Sue Allen, Joe Bliss, Helora Danna, Kaileigh Fiorillo, Mia Cherise Hall, Amelie Jacobs, Gryphyn Karimloo, Mary Mondlock, Ren Parker, Moana Poyer, Alyssa Wray
Music Director: Jorden Amir
Bass: Tony Gnerre
Drums: Ethan Gueldenzopf
November 4th, 2022